The Receivershipof Dellis Cay through Unit Trust Cooperation of Trinidad& Tobago
TTUTC is a financial services company (“the Bank”) operating in Trinidad and Tobago. The Bank’s Merchant Banking department undertakes the origination, structuring, marketing and public pricing of public offerings and private placements of equity-related securities as well as debt securities for local and regional corporations, institutions and regional governments.
Despite my attempts to cooperate and assist the Bank to understand the issues surrounding the leak of the unredacted report, and the issues surrounding Turks Development Ltd, which has made the political contribution to the ex-Premier Missick on Jan 2007, and the political risks associated with Turks Ltd, The Bank has changed its position vis-à-vis the Company, its directors, despite a strong letter of comfort that it had provided.
On 27 August 2009, I have met the Bank’s Board in their Board Room, in Trinidad. They asked about the Commission of Inquiry in Turks and Caicos Islands and whether the Bank’s funds were used for political donation. We have responded that the political contribution in question was made on January 2007, well before any relation with the Bank. Furthermore, we have provided a plan and additional security to the TTUTC.
As a result of the Governor’s and Bank’s negligence, we have suffered loss and damage and as result, on 15 October 2009, a Receiver was appointed by the Bank.
To date, $174 million has been spent on Dellis Cay . The development has gone into receivership due largely to the adverse publicity generated by the unlawful publication of the complete (unredacted) version of the final report of the TCI Commission of Inquiry.
I had provided the funding bank, TTUTC a personal guarantee for the entire loan. On 22nd of January TTUTC has obtained “a worldwide freezing order/mareva with an ancillary disclosure of assets order” from the Supreme Court of Turks and Caicos Islands against me and my partner Oguz Serim. Since that date, proceedings continue. We have filed a counter claim against TTUTC, for the breach of confidentiality that caused our collapse, as their lawyers spread the word that they will put our company in receivership, well before the action was taken by them.
On January 2011, the Court has issued a Mareva Injunction against me and my partner. We have still this injunction.
I have appealed the decision on March 2011. To date the appeal is not heard.More as 10 years are gone without any progress.
Since the receivership of my companies, I could fund my personal expenses, and my legal costs from the proceeds of the sale of my personal house in Miami. The proceeds of the sale were placed in escrow by the order of the Court and I could only use it by the order of the same.
The funds through sale of lots, villas or residences on Dellis Cay NEVER have been wired directly to the accounts of our company. The purchasers paid their installments into accounts of the TTUTC! TTUTC sent the funds after confirmation of their quantity survey to the construction company.
In the last months before receivership TTUTC stopped the wire transfers for progress of the construction works.
Publishing of unredacted report of Inquiry and following negligence of the TTUTC has brought the owner company of Dellis Cay in receivership.
Me, my partner and purchasers of Dellis Cay have lost all of their assets.
All the years after receivership all of our actions to find a solution with TTUTC and to continue with construction of Dellis Cay were without any result.
TTUTC has ignored any contact.
TTUTC has destroyed our and purchasers assets.
12 years after receivership I am appealing for just and progress.
I am calling on Premier Hon. Washington Missick, Deputy Premier EJ Saunders and His Excellency the Governor Nigel Dakin to stop any transaction because of unlawful sale of my property and make me and my partners and purchasers a part of a solution for this development.
I am publishing one of several letters to TTUTC (the last one )
Dr CEM KINAY
Wednesday, December 23, 2020
Mr. Nigel Edwards Executive Director TTUTC
RE: DELLIS CAY
Dear Mr. Edwards
I hope that this letter finds you well. We have never met. I am Dr. Cem Kinay, the founder of Turks Ltd, the company that has being developing Mandarin Oriental Dellis Cay at Turks and Caicos Islands until our business ran into difficulties due to the political crisis in the Turks and Caicos Islands back in 2009, some 11 years ago. I believe that the circumstances are very different now and there may be a possibility to continue to the development of my beloved project.
I am contacting you in order to communicate to you that I have investors interested to acquire Dellis Cay and in this regard, I would appreciate if you could provide my investors an opportunity to understand the current conditions for sale for this property that is in your possession.
It has been my effort to save Dellis Cay for many years, and I hope this time my investors can meet your requirements. My aim is to complete Dellis Cay as soon as possible
My investors and I are the best suited people to carry on this development, as we have the knowledge, experience, how to build on that island at affordable budgets. I don’t expect any other party to be able to deliver the same construction quality, speed, and cost within a short time-frame, i.e. 15 months from the commencement of construction once we are all ready to commence Dellis Cay.
I have decided to approach you personally as I believe you can place me at the right direction.
Statement of Dr. Cem Kinay on Dellis Cay and Joe Grant
I understand from Turks and Caicos Islands sources Slot Bet Rendah that Dellis Cay, our private island development is under offer.
Since 2009, I have Slot Gacor Maxwin been living stripped of my basic human rights and my assets in Turks and Caicos Islands. It has been 13 years since my name was leaked in an unredacted Commission of Inquiry report in 2008, and
10 years since a TCI Court has Slot Pragmatic concluded we obtained benefits because of a perfectly legal political donation to Hon. Michael Misick, then the Premier.
As a Slot Bet Kecil result of allegations, Trinidad Tobago Unit Trust Corporation has appointed a receiver to Dellis Cay and placed our land for sale back in 20009.
Then, only 200 acres of Joe Grant Cay which Slot Maxwin we acquired for 3.2 million at an alleged “undervalue” with the approval of TCI Governor Richard Tauwhare is sold for 4.04 million for whole island, to private investors back in 2013.
The allegations Slot Bet Kecil 100 that Joe Grant Cay was worth much more than what we paid for, proved to be completely rootless.
The TCI courts did not admit our expert witness statements, valuations, and our appeals were not heard. This transaction is unlawful, and we will go in 2022 to Human Rights Court for this unlawful transaction.
In fact, there was no “favor” from anyone for any of my developments in TCI. I have been simply victimized by politics. My assets were frozen, and hundreds of people lost their jobs. A Slot Gacor Hari Ini lot of villa and residence purchasers lost their assets too.
I will Slot Maxwin continue my legal actions for Dellis Cay as any cost and will not leave this private island which I have paid my hard-earned funds to acquire from its private owner in 2005. I have spent years planning, designing, organizing, and attracting internationally repute designers,
like Zaha Hadid, Piero Lissoni, Shigeru Ban, Kengo Kuma, David Chipperfield, Carl Ettensperger, Chad Oppenheim, hotel operators like Mandarin Oriental Hotels and Bulgari Hotels, as RTP Slot Tertinggi well as customers for this development and
I will not let it go.
I am calling on Premier Hon. Washington Missick, Deputy Premier EJ Saunders and His Excellency the Governor, Nigel Dakin to stop any RTP Live transaction because of unlawful sale of my property and make me and my partners and purchasers a part of the solution for this development.
On 10 July 2008 the Governor of the Turks & Caicos islands appointed Sir Robin Auld to conduct an Inquiry into possible corruption or other serious dishonesty in recent years of past and present elected members of the legislature. Public hearings were held in the course of January and February of this year. There were 20 counts of allegations against Mr. Misick, who resigned due to those various allegations.
Most of the existing developers in the Turks and Caicos Islands were also mentioned during the Commission’s work. In the course of the hearings, among many other developers, and questions, It was put to politicians that Joe Grant Cay has been sold to me in June 2008 and my partners at an undervalue and that a political donation of US$500,000 in January 2007, made by myself shortly before an early election called by the Premier Michael Misick , was a bribe connected with negotiations that were underway at that time in connection with the purchase of Joe Grant’s Cay.
No request was ever made by the Inquiry to me to give evidence, but nonetheless wrote to the Inquiry setting with an expression of my concern to allegations in circumstances which were grossly unfair and a breach of the principles of natural justice.
Furthermore, I have made preparations with our UK lawyers for any possible investigation concerning the valuation of this property together with the details of the political contribution. In that respect: We have finalized with CB Richard Ellis, Savills of UK , Ernst & Young as well as local appraisers such as CASL, BCQS, and Concept Plus, numerous valuation reports of Joe Grant Cay as of June 30, 2008. We have collected evidence, and records of the political contribution made in Jan 2007, including confirmation letters from our banks, that demonstrate that the contribution was in fact no secret, and could not be construed as a bribe. It is perfectly legal to make political donations in the Turks and Caicos Islands.
The Judicial Review
Against the risk of being named in the Auld Report, we have asked the High Court of Turks and Caicos Islands to Judicially Review the Final Report, and deal with any mention of Joe Grant Cay, and Dellis Cay and myself, if any.
The Supreme Court of Turks and Caicos Islands called for the removal of any adverse reference to me or my companies from the Final Report of the Turks and Caicos Islands Commission of Inquiry. In his ruling, His Lordship the Chief Justice of the Turks and Caicos Supreme Court, Gordon Ward OBE agreed with my counsel, Clare Montgomery QC, that there was a “clear and almost total failure by the Commission to follow its own procedures.”
The Chief Justice in his Judgment stated that I have not been given a fair hearing:
“I am satisfied that Dr. Kinay has not been given a fair hearing and that
even the limited terms of the Salmon letter do not remedy the earlier
errors. He had a legitimate expectation that the Commission would follow
its own procedures in respect of a person considered to be implicated and
it failed to do so.
The final allegations did not arise from the evidence to
which he replied on 30 January 2009 and he had no indication that further
allegations would be raised against him entirely without notice. “
“The Commission clearly has the right to recommend that there be further
investigation of a named person but the manner in which the reasons for
any such recommendation were obtained and presented to the public
hearing were so clearly in breach of the recognised standards of fairness
that they must be ultra vires the Commission’s powers. If included in the
Final Report, they should not be published or mentioned in any statements
about the case.”
The Public Leak
Early on Saturday July 18th 2009, the Turks and Caicos Commission of Inquiry
published a redacted version of Sir Robin Auld’s Final Report. The purpose of
redacting the report insofar as it related to Dr. Kinay was to remove adverse
references to me and my companies. However, as His Excellency the Governor
later acknowledged, it became apparent that it was possible to access the
unredacted text and I asked him to take steps to have the Final Report removed
from the Commission’s website.
By July 21st, 2009 it had become apparent that the unredacted report was widely
available. In response to evidence of that and an application by Turks and Caicos
Weekly News and WIV Channel 4 News Dr. Kinay did not seek the continuation
of the injunction. It was accepted that Dr. Kinay was an innocent victim of the
disclosure of the unredacted report. Those adverse references had been made
unfairly. Regrettably they have now been given publicity. That does not make
them fair when they are not.
We have also received a letter from the Attorney General of Turks and Caicos
Islands,. The letter expresses the Governor’s regrets with his unreserved apologies
to Dr Cem Kinay, director of Turks Ltd. The Governor’s apology relates to the
discovery of the possibility of uncovering the redacted parts of the TCI
Commission of Inquiry Final Report which was posted on the Commission’s
website early on Saturday July 18th 2009. The purpose of redacting the report
insofar as it related to Dr. Kinay was to remove adverse references to Dr Kinay
and his companies. The Chief Justice had found on June 18th, 2009 that the
adverse findings made against Dr. Kinay were unlawful and that it is unlawful for
Dellis Cay is a pristine island situated in the Turks and Caicos Islands, a British Overseas Territory. It is a 20 minute boat ride from the main island of Providenciales and next to Parrot Cay.
Dellis Cay would be the most spoken project worldwide with an investment of one billion USD and would be home for around 100 families from around the world and around 1000 TCI people would get a job at world best hotel company Mandarin Oriental .
I am sure Dellis Cay ,when would be completed and opened in 2010 ,would change the whole destiny of Turks and Caicos Island.
I have today still the same belief.My involvement in the TCI dates from early 2005 at which time I was seeking development opportunities for the development company, the O Property Collection Gmbh, Austria which was also owned beneficially by the Austrian Foundations. The aim of O Property Collection was to leverage my and my partner Oguz Serim’s successful background in luxury resort development and management. We are highly regarded in that industry. I was introduced to Donatella Zignone Dini, then the owner of Dellis Cay, a private island of 560 acres of which 220 acres were privately owned by one of her companies Dellis Cay Development Company Ltd (DCDC), and the remaining 340 acres TCIG owned in the Turks and Caicos Islands. As of 30 June 2005, Dellis Cay had no Development Agreement, therefore no zoning, no permits, no water, some roads, and an underground electricity line passing through the island. Turks Ltd bought the island for US$18 million.
I have on November 2006 signed a management and branding agreement with Mandarin Oriental Hotel Group for the branding and management of Dellis Cay.
I have hired for this exceptional development worlds best and well known architects, design partners.
SHIGERU BAN
PARIS, FRANCE / TOKYO, JAPAN
Shigeru Ban, born in Tokyo, studied at the Southern California Institute of Architecture from 1977 to 1980, and graduated from the Cooper Union School of Architecture in 1984. He was apprenticed in the studios of Arata Isozaki from 1982-83 and in 1985 he opened his own studios in Tokyo. In 1996 he was awarded the Kansai Architect Grand Prize and the first prize in the Mainichi Design Award. Ban is known for his research into the use of economic materials, especially Paper Tube structure. His recent projects include the Japanese Pavilion at Expo 2000, and the New Pompidou Centre in Metz, France. He also worked for the UNHCR to develop refugee’s shelters in Rwanda and disaster relief houses after earthquakes in Kobe (1995), Turkey (1999), India (2001) and the Tsunami in Sri Lanka (2004).
Ban would undertake the construction of the Caribbean’s first true over-the-water villas in Dellis Cay’s “South Beach” Lifestyle Zone. Each villa would l be divided into a main villa located on the beach and a floating house that will be entirely surrounded by water and linked to the beach by a discreet floating deck. Ban would also design one of the “The West Beach Estates,” located at the most desirable location on Dellis Cay and enjoying the longest beachfront and the largest villas. A sparsely developed Lifestyle Zone with most of the natural vegetation of the cay intact, the West Beach Estates will offer magnificent views of the reef located just offshore.
DAVID CHIPPERFIELD
LONDON, UK
David Chipperfield trained at the Architectural Association in London and worked for Douglas Stephen, Richard Rogers and Norman Foster. He was a founding member and director of the 9H Gallery and a trustee of the Architecture Foundation. He is currently Professor of Architecture at the Staatliche Akademie der Bildenden Künste in Stuttgart. David Chipperfield Architects was established in 1984, and has since undertaken work in Europe, Japan and the US. In 1997, Chipperfield won a major competition to redevelop the Neues Museum, one of the most important public buildings in Berlin, involving its reconstruction and re-interpretation as a historical monument. In 1999, he was awarded the Tessenow Gold Medal, and in 2004 he was appointed Commander of the Order of the British Empire (CBE) for services to architecture.
David Chipperfield Architects would be responsible for design and development of the “North Beach” Lifestyle Zone at Dellis Cay. The North Beach development lies on a natural peninsula, enjoying spectacular views of both the neighboring island of Parrot Cay to the north and the island’s mangrove interior to the south. David Chipperfield Architects would develop modern luxury villas, each with at least 150 feet of ocean frontage affording direct access to the channel that connects Dellis Cay and Parrot Cay.
Chipperfield would also design one of the “The West Beach Estates,” located at the most desirable location on Dellis Cay and enjoying the longest beachfront and the largest villas. A sparsely developed Lifestyle Zone with most of the natural vegetation of the cay intact, the West Beach Estates will offer magnificent views of the reef located just offshore.
CARL ETTENSPERGER
SINGAPORE, SINGAPORE
Carl Ettensperger, Managing Director of C&C Studio, a Singapore-based boutique design studio, is a graduate from the Art Centre College of Design, Pasadena, Calif. His illustrious career includes being an MD of Hirsch/Bedner & Associates (HBA)
and Wimberly Allison Tong Goo (WATG), Singapore, as well as setting up his own company, Interior Design Network International Pte Ltd (IDNI), in 1996. C&C Studio was established in 2001. He has been involved in some of the most prestigious mega-projects in the hospitality industry, including The Residence Hotel in Tunisia; Grand Hyatt, Taipei; St George’s Terrace, Australia; Grand Hyatt, Bali; The Canyon Ranch Spa Club, Las Vegas; The Park, Calcutta; Hyatt Regency, Kathmandu, Nepal; Canyon Ranch Health Resort; and the Bali Hyatt Spa in Indonesia. Some of his more recently completed projects are The Living Room, Marriott Hotel, Singapore; the Mandarin Oriental Hotel, Hong Kong; Leela Palace Hotel in Bangalore and Bombay and the Hilton, Maldives.
Carl Ettensperger has also been selected to develop over-the-water villas in Dellis Cay’s “South Beach” Zone. These water villas will be created in a style reminiscent of traditional Asian architecture, and will be adjacent to the over-water restaurant, a main attraction on the island, where residents and guests will enjoy fine dining on the pristine beach.Carl Ettensperger died in 2013.RIP for him.
ZAHA HADID
LONDON, UK
Zaha Hadid studied architecture at the Architectural Association in London, where she was awarded the Diploma Prize in 1977. Hadid began her own practice in 1979 with the design of an apartment in Eaton Place, London, which was awarded the Architectural Design Gold Medal in 1982. Since then, Hadid has won many awards, and most recently was the recipient of the 2004 Pritzker Architecture Prize. Hadid’s past projects include Strasbourg (2000), JVC Hotel Guadalajara (2000), National Library of Quebec Montreal (2000), and Bergisel Ski Jump Innsbruck (1999), among others. Hadid has won many awards for her work, and most recently was the recipient of the 2004 Pritzker Architecture Prize.
Hadid has been commissioned to oversee the Dellis Cay Master Plan, as well to design the futuristic-themed “Marina” Lifestyle Zone, which includes luxury condos and a hotel, a number of beachfront villas, a commercial building with restaurants and boutiques, a marina with 110 slips and 4 to 5 mega-yachts, and a lighthouse. The Marina Zone will encompass fluid architecture that uses water as a common design element, both outside and inside the marina space. Hadid will also design the one of the “The West Beach Estates,” located at the most desirable location on Dellis Cay and enjoying the longest beachfront and the largest villas. A sparsely developed Lifestyle Zone with most of the natural vegetation of the cay intact, the West Beach Estates will offer magnificent views of the reef located just offshore.Zaha Hadid died in 2016.RIP Zaha Hadid
KENGO KUMA
TOKYO, JAPAN
Kengo Kuma established Kengo Kuma & Associates in 1990. The architect’s numerous residential works, museums, and other public facilities have received on-going critical acclaim and have won several national and international awards including the prestigious Architectural Institute of Japan Award in 1997. Recent projects include LVMH Group’s Japan headquarters completed in 2003, Suntory’s new Tokyo office building, and the Kodan Shinonome apartments completed in 2004, as well as the Great (Bamboo) Wall House – a structure formed primarily of glass and Chinese bamboo – outside of Beijing, completed in 2002. In addition to a professorship at Keio University’s Faculty of Science and Technology since 2001, Kuma frequently lectures at other institutions.
Kengo Kuma has been commissioned to create the “Spa” Lifestyle Zone at Dellis Cay, including what will be known as the Spa Lake Villas as well as the exclusive and exotic Resort Spa. Kuma would also design the one of the “The West Beach Estates,” located at the most desirable location on Dellis Cay and enjoying the longest beachfront and the largest villas. A sparsely developed Lifestyle Zone with most of the natural vegetation of the cay intact, the West Beach Estates will offer magnificent views of the reef located just offshore.
PIERO LISSONI
MILAN, ITALY
Born in 1956, Piero Lissoni started his career as a designer in 1978.
After his Architecture degree at Milan Polytechnic, he started his collaboration with Boffi in 1985. Together with Nicoletta Canesi, Piero Lissoni founded Lissoni Associati (1986) and Graph.x (1996) developing projects of Architecture, Interiors, Industrial and Graphic Design in addition to Art Direction and Corporate Image. Among his clients : Alessi, Boffi, Cappellini, Cassina, Flos, Fritz Hansen, Glas, Kartell, Knoll International, Lema, Living Divani, Matteograssi,Poltrona Frau, Porro, Tecno, Thonet and Wella. Among his recent interior realisations: interiors of the Shangri La Hotel & Resort in Miami; a private villa near Como.
In Venice, restoration and furnishing of all common areas of the luxury Hotel “Monaco and Grand Canal” and the Bacaro Bar, a multifunctional space bar-library-restaurant adjacent to Hotel Monaco; in Istanbul the Bentley design hotel ; in Switzerland the “Al Porto” Hotel by the Zurich Lake; in Tokyo the “Mitsui Garden” business Hotel in the trendy neighbourhood of Ginza.
In November 2005, Piero Lissoni received one of the highest recognition in the design world: the prize “Hall of Fame of Interior Design” in the occasion of a reception in New York Waldorf Astoria and more recently the “Best Kitchen 2005” Elle Décor International Award for“ Table System ” Boffi kitchen .
Lissoni would be responsible for architectural and interior design of Dellis Cay Phase I, comprised of the main Mandarin Oriental Hotel with ultra-luxury penthouses, residences, and beach villas. The Hotel building will accommodate general areas such as the lobby, restaurants, bars, and pool. Lissoni will also design the one of the “The West Beach Estates,” located at the most desirable location on Dellis Cay and enjoying the longest beachfront and the largest villas. A sparsely developed Lifestyle Zone with most of the natural vegetation of the cay intact, the West Beach Estates will offer magnificent views of the reef located just offshore.
On June 2008, the construction started and continued on Dellis Cay until October 2009.
The Dellis Cay development was funded by a mixture of funds from us, sales of residential lots and loans from the Trinidad and Tobago Unit Trust Corporation.
The development proceeded in an unremarkable fashion from that date with the usual succession of planning applications (46 so far) and permits obtained.
Here is my story: 1. I practiced medicine at the General Hospital of Vienna in Austria. I received my PhD from the University of Vienna Medical School in 1984. I am Austrian Citizen, Belonger of Turks and Caicos Islands. I was born in Istanbul Turkey, graduated from Austrian school in Istanbul in 1977. 2. In 1987, Magister Oguz Serim, my other Austrian citizen partner, and I set up a tour operator by the name of Gulet Touristik, the largest tour operator in Austria. In 1990, Mr Serim and I founded the first ” All Inclusive Hotel Operator” in Europe, the Magic Life Group (“Magic Life”). Magic Life owned and managed luxury properties in Turkey, Austria, Greece, Tunisia, Spain,Egypt and Bulgaria. In 1997, Mr Serim and I established a further tour operator, Gulet Touropa Touristik. In 2004, we sold Magic Life and Gulet Touristik to the German tourism group TUI AG, one of the world’s largest tour operators. 3. I am widely recognized for my contributions to the travel industry, In 1996 I was lauded as Austria’s “Tourism Manager of the Year” and
in 1997, as “Man of the Year” and
finally on 2006, I have been honored with “State Medal Of Austria”
My partner Oguz has also been provided with the same honor. 4. Mr. Serim and I have founded 2 Austrian Foundations and all proceeds of the Magic Life sale was donated to the Foundations. Foundations owned beneficially Turks Ltd, a Turks and Caicos Islands ordinary company incorporated in the Turks and Caicos Islands (“the TCI”) a British Overseas Territory in the West Indies according advise of our well known lawyers in Providenciales and Miami. The Dellis Cay project 5. My involvement in the TCI dates from early 2005 at which time I was seeking development opportunities for the development company, the O Property Collection Gmbh, Austria which was also owned beneficially by the Austrian 2 foundations . The aim of O Property Collection was to leverage my and my partner Oguz Serim’s successful background in luxury resort development and management. They are highly regarded in that industry. 6. I was introduced to Donatella Zignone Dini, then the owner of Dellis Cay, a private island of 560 acres of which 220 acres were privately owned by one of her companies Dellis Cay Development Company Ltd (DCDC), and the remaining 340 acres TCIG owned in the Turks and Caicos Islands. As of 30 June 2005, Dellis Cay had no Development Agreement, therefore no zoning, no permits, no water, some roads, and an underground electricity line passing through the island. Turks Ltd bought the island for US$18 million.
Statement of Dr Cem Kinay with respect to Joe Grant Cay Undervalue Allegation
Istanbul, Turkey – 2February 2016
I have read in recent news that it is alleged that Joe Grant Cay, a Crown land, was valued at $75 million but was sold to my companies for $3 million.
I can not afford lawyers as Turks and Caicos Islands Courts have frozen all my worldwide assets not allowing me to spend any funds towards my right to defend myself and my companies, but I will make this statement today to set the record straight.
The allegations against Joe Grant Cay and myself are totally baseless. It is claimed that 200 acres of the 710 acres of the Joe Grant Cay Island was purchased at an alleged undervalue in June 2008. The undervalue claim is based on a set of confused valuation reports prepared by the Government’s Valuation Officer, Mr. Shaban Hoza which was different from the valuation report prepared again for the Government, instructed by Hon. Governor Richard Tauwhare in June 2008 , by an independent accredited commercial appraiser in TCI, BCQS who valued 200 acres of Joe Grant Cay, at USD 3.2 million for commercial use, exactly the amount of money asked by the Government in June 2008, which my development companies have paid in full. It is significant that his Hon. Governor increased the price on the back of the BCQS valuation report from USD 2 million to USD 3.2 million.
Following our purchase, I have obtained 5 more valuation reports to justify the price of this transaction, 2 from local valuation companies and 3 from internationally repute appraisers: CB Richard Ellis and Ernst & Young in the USA; and Savills of UK which all agreed on similar valuation levels of the BCQS report which was the just and fair value of this Crown land.
The Development Agreement of Joe Grant on the other hand, was negotiated over almost 2 years with the Attorney General’s Chambers before Hon. Governor Whetherell and Hon. Rhondalee Braithwaite executed it on behalf of the Crown on 7 November 2008. Joe Grant Cay Development Agreement signed by Hon. Governor Whetherell does not contain any privileges, favors or better conditions than any other Development Agreements signed by him or any other recent development agreements signed by previous Hon. Governors. All negotiations were dealt over almost two years by the development companies professional management team, our lawyer Owen Foley at Misick & Stanbrook, my joint venture partner’s lawyer Mr. Chal Misick, Attorney General’s Chambers and TCI Invest.
For the past 6 years, I have been living stripped of my basic human rights and assets just because the TCI Courts have concluded in connection with a political donation made to Michael Misick on 9 January 2007 “there to be a very strong probability that the money was paid as a bribe in order to ensure that the Defendant companies obtained the benefit of the proposed (Joe Grant Cay) development” disregarding the evidence that I have sent, stating that I was “late” sending evidence to the trial. My appeals were rejected and TCI Government has taken Joe Grant Cay back from my companies only to sell the same Crown Land, Joe Grant Cay for USD 4.04 million in October 2013.
For those who doubt that the development of Joe Grant Cay is not innocent, I have the following to ask: We have paid 3.2 million in 2008 for this 200 acre land, 5 years later, the same land has been sold for 4.04 million in an open market transaction ! I ask you what happened to the alleged tens of millions of dollars that the Government and some of our opponents claimed that this land was supposed to be worth?
I have the answer: The alleged valuation of this island was a big lie ! Joe Grant Cay’s 200 acre was never valued more than what we paid for. That was the exact reason why many internationally repute valuation companies as well as all the local valuation companies have valued it at the exact value that we paid for it. That is why both Hon. Governor Tauwhare, and later on Hon. Governor Whetherell have approved and executed the sale of this 200 Acre land to us for USD 3.2 million, and that was why the sale was approved by the Attorney General, TCI Invest, Ministers, and the Premier and Hon. Rhondalee Braithwaite, Deputy Attorney General back then. Do you really believe that they were all ‘deceived’? and did not know what they were selling?
In fact, there was no “favor” from anyone for Joe Grant Cay. In fact, we have paid the true value of this land, and the shameless dark forces took away from us alleging the “undervalue” sale.
The people of Turks and Caicos Islands was going to benefit from Joe Grant Cay development as this project was going to provide a sustainable source of income for the local economy. Today, we could have celebrated the opening Dellis Cay, and the commencement of construction at Joe Grant Cay. These could have provided much needed employment opportunities. I have seen the progress in North Caicos with my own eyes during Dellis Cay’s construction and I have no doubt new businesses could have flourished both in North and Middle Caicos if we could complete what we had started.
In the past years, I have been victimized by politics. My assets were frozen and hundreds of people lost their jobs.
I am calling upon the TCI Government and the Attorney General to end these groundless accusations against me, return my assets, and clear my name as I have done nothing wrong. I have spent all my wealth in Turks and Caicos Islands, and lost most of my investments, lot of purchasers lost their investments too.
I still desire to realize my dreams concerning Dellis Cay and Joe Grant Cay. I have spent all my life in building my reputation. My life is full of success stories and honors. I intend to spend the rest of my life to defend these honors.
Turizmci Cem Kınay, 2005’te Turks&Caicos adalarında başladığı proje adalardaki rüşvet skandalı nedeniyle durunca zor günler geçirdi. Turks&Caicos’ta açılan davalar sürerken, Cem Kınay, New York Bölge Mahkemesi’nde aleyhine açılan davayı kazandı.
ORTAKLARIYLA birlikte turizme Magic Life markasını kazandırıp, daha sonra elden çıkaran Cem Kınay’ın hayatı, 2005’te rüya gibi bir proje gerçekleştirmek için gittiği Turks&Caicos Adaları’nda patlayan ‘rüşvet skandalı’ nedeniyle kabusa döndü. İsmi adada patlayan rüşvet skandalına karışınca iddialı gayrimenkul projesi duran Kınay, ev satın alan 30 malikten 7’sinin New York Bölge Mahkemesi’nde açtığı davayı kazandı. Cem Kınay, İngiltere’nin kontrolündeki Turks and Caicos Adaları’nda hem ada hükümeti hem de kredi aldıkları bankayla davalık olduklarını hatırlatarak, “Siyasi baskıdan muaf ABD’de davayı kazandık. Bunun adada süren diğer iki davamıza da örnek teşkil edeceğini ve olumlu yansıyacağını düşünüyorum” dedi.
En büyük üzüntüsünü projenin yarım kalması olarak açıklayan Cem Kınay, şöyle konuştu: “Ben en başından beri bankayla ve yerel hükümetle anlaşarak bu projeyi bitirme derdindeyim. Bize güvenenlerin mağdur olmasını hiç istemem. Bırakıp gitmedim. Tek amacım bu projeyi bitirmek. Maddi zararımın yanı sıra zedelenen itibarımı da temizleyip bu projeyi bitirmeye kararlıyım.”
Bankayla temasa başladık
Projeyi bitirmek uğruna banka ile yeniden temasa geçtiğini anlatan Kınay, “Onlara mektup yazıp insanların mağdur olmaması için bu projenin tamamlanması gerektiğini söyledim. Davalar uzun sürüyor. Davaların bitmesini beklemeyelim, dedim. Burada da olumlu gelişme bekliyorum” dedi. Cem Kınay adada patlayan rüşvet skandalını şöyle hatırlattı: “Karayipler’deki bu adalar İngiltere’ye, yani Birleşik Krallık’a bağlı. Krallık, adalarda rüşvet soruşturması başlattı. Başbakan, aldığı siyasi bağışların listesini mahkemeye verdi. Siyasi bağış ABD gibi pekçok ülkede de var ve yasal. Biz de resmi yollardan banka kanalıyla bir bağış yapmıştık. Resmi bağış yapmış bir şirket olarak ismimizin rüşvet verenler listesinden çıkarılması için dava açtık. Mahkeme başkanı bizi haklı buldu. Ama İngiltere’nin adaya atadığı vali, hukukuz bir iş yaparak ismimizin geçtiği listeyi internette yayınladı. Bunun üzerine kredi aldığımız banka rahatsız oldu. Projeden ev alanlar ödemelerini kesti. Sonra banka işimize el koydu. İnşaat durdu. Turks ve Caicos’ta parlamento kapatıldı. Siyasi bir darbe yaşandı. Ben de bu olayların politik kurbanıyım.”
Cem Kınay kimdir
AVUSTURYA Devlet Nişanı sahibi olan Cem Kınay’ın yaşamından bazı satır başları şöyle:
Viyana Üniversite Hastanesinde doktor olarak çalıştı.
1987’de ortağı Oğuz Serim ile Avusturya’nın en büyük tur operatörü Gulet Touristik’i kurdu.
Türkiye, Yunanistan, Tunus, İspanya, Avusturya, Mısır ve Bulgaristan’a yayılan Magic Life otel zincirini 1990’da kurdu.
2004’te Magic Life ve Gulet Touristik’i dünyanın en büyük tur operatörlerinden TUI AG’ye sattılar.
Bol ödül alacak proje gözüyle bakılıyordu
CEM Kinay, Turks and Caicos adalarında Kengo Kuma, Zaha Hadid, Piero Lissoni, Shigeru Ban, David Chipperfield, ve Carl Ettensperger gibi dünyanın önde gelen mimarlarından bazılarının eşsiz tasarımlarını içeren lüks bir ada tatil kompleksi oluşturduklarını hatırlattı. Kınay, “Tamamlandığında, proje Mandarin Oriental Hotel, lüks villalardan ve çevresindeki yerleşim birimlerinden oluşacaktı. Bol ödül alacak proje gözüyle bakılıyordu. Projenin inşaatı Haziran 2008’de başladı ve Ekim 2009’da bu politik sebepler yüzünden durdu” diye konuştu.
Bu makale 08.Nisan.2012 de Hurriyette yayinlandi.Demet Cengiz
Avusturya’da tarihin en başarılı turizm girişimcisi olan Cem Kınay, Karayipler’de ilgisi Slot Gacor Terpercaya olmayan bir siyasi kavganın içine iradesi dışında sürüklendi ve İnterpol’den hakkında kırmızıbülten çıkarıldı.
Bir subayın oğlu olan Türk Cem Kınay, Avusturya’da doktor olduktan sonra, ihtisası sırasında sıfırdan kurduğu turizm işinde, seyahat pazarının %60’ına hakim olarak bir turizmimparatorluğu kurdu. Turizm şirketi Gulet ile birlikte sahibi olduğu 19 adet Magic Lifeotellerine yılda yüz binlerce Avusturyalı’yı tatile gönderdi. Bugün ise 54 yaşındaki Cem Kınay varını yoğunu kaybetmek tehlikesi ile karşı karşıya. Oysa o sadece, şirketler grubunun 2004 yılında gerçekleştirilen Almanya seyahat devi TUI’ye satışından sonra bir başkavizyonunu gerçekleştirmek istiyordu. Issız bir adanın geliştirilerek turizme kazandırılması.
2005 yılında Karayip sahillerindeki Dellis Cay’in beyaz sahiline ilk defa ayağını bastığında“İşte o ada burası” dedi.
İngiliz müstemlekesi Turks and Caicos BO Slot Online adalarına ait olan 560 hektar büyüklüğündeki bu küçük adayı bir İtalyan asilzadesinden 18 milyon dolar’a satın aldı. Burası tüm dünya elitleri için lüks bir tatil cenneti olacaktı. Zaha Hadid’den Pierro Lisoni’ye kadar dünyanın en önemli mimarlarından yedi tanesi villalar, apartmanlar ve Mandarin Oriental Group için lüks bir otel tasarımı yaptı.
Mimari dergiler proje hakkında “dünyanın en trendy mimari kum adası” yazıyordu. Kınay tüm birikimlerini bu işe yatırdı. Ve başkalarını da yatırima ikna etti.
Ancak, Turks and Caicos’un Başbakanı Michael Misick ile birlikte gerçekleştirdiği temel atma töreninde Kınay, Karayipler rüyasının çok yakın zamanda bir kabusa dönüşeceğini tahmin etmiyordu. İktidar partisi seçimlerden önce bir cok orada is yapan is adamiyla beraber bağış için onun da kapısını çaldı. Kınay “Bağış talebini avukatlarıma sordum. Bana parti bağışlarının tamamen yasal olduğunu beyan ettiler” dedi. “Şirketim de “tamamen açık, şeffaf ve yasal” bir şekilde 500.000 dolar bağış yaptı.” Bir süre sonra çıkan bir kasırga sonrası parti yeniden bağış talebinde bulundu ve Kınay’ın şirketi 200.000 dolar daha bağışta bulundu.
Bu cömertlik onun kötü kaderi haline gelecekti. 2008 yılının Ağustos ayında Büyük BritanyaDevleti ağır yolsuzluk suçlamalarından ötürü Misick’i görevden alıp parlamentoyu feshetti ve adaların özerk yönetimini düzenleyen anayasayı yürürlükten kaldırdı. Bu konuyla ilvili olarak siyasi gözlemciler İngilizlerde, Turks and Caicoslular’ın Kanada’ya bağlanma tercihleri ve daha da ötesi tam bağımsızlık taleplerine yönelik bir çabanın rahatsızlığı olduğunu tahmin ediyorlar.
Kınay bu olaylardan önce İngiltere Kraliçe’sine ait bir başka adanın daha bir kısmını satın almıştı. Joe Grant adlı bu adanın 200 hektarı için şirketleri 3,2 milyon dolar ödedi ve bir sonraki projesini hayata geçirmek üzere çalışmalara başladı. Yine bir otel ve villalar yapılmak üzere yola çıkılan bu projede de ortağı İtalya Lüks Grubu Bulgari idi.
İngilizler tarafından görevlendirilen adanın yeni sömürge valisi, Kınay’ı hükümete rüşvet verdiği için ada hissesini ucuza elde ettiğini iddia ederek kendisine asılsız suçlamalarda bulundu. Daha sonra ise her şey ardı ardına geldi. Araştırma komisyonunu henuz sonuçlanmamamış ve hatalı ara raporu yerel medyaya sızdırıldı. Bunun üzerine Dellis Cay projesine finansman sağlayan Trinidad and Tobago Unit Trust Corporation bankası vermiş olduğu krediyi geri çağırdı. İngilizler de hükümet hakkındaki rüşvet soruşturması için bir özel yetkili savcı tayin ettiler. Dellis Cay de insaat durduruldu ve her iki ada da kayyum yönetimine bırakıldı. O günden beri, yani üç yıldır yarısı bitmiş olan binalar artık yıpranma tehlikesi ile karşı karşıya. Burada mağdur olan sadece Kınay olmadı.İnşaatın ilerlemesine istinaden onunla beraber bu işe girerek 100 milyon dolar yatırmış olan diğer yatırımcılar da mağdur oldu.
Kınay bütün bunların sonucunda kendisini yerel ve İngiliz menfaat grupları arasındaki siyasi bir kavganın kurbanı olarak görüyor. Herşeyi sıfırdan kendi kendine yaratan girişimci işadamı Kınay, Istanbul Maslak Sheraton Otelinde yapılan KURIER röportajında “Joe Grant adasının alımında sözleşme partneri hükümet değil, tam tersine bir önceki İngiliz sömürge valisi idi. Fiyatı o belirletti, inceledi ve satış sözleşmesini imzaladı” diye vurguladı. Nitekim, aralarında Richard Ellis ile Ernst&Young şirketlerinin de olduğu bağımsız beş denetleme şirketinin raporlarında da, adanın satış sözleşmesindeki aynı fiyat tespit edilmişti.
Kınay “Kimseye rüşvet vermedim ve daha başlangıçtan beri savcılık ile tam işbirliği yaptım” diyor.
2011 yılı Ekim ayında İstanbul’da kendi isteği ile yapılan sorgulamadan sonra savcılıktan bir daha haber almadı. Ta ki Turks and Caicos’un talebi üzerine İnterpol Temmuz ayı başlarında “Kırmızı bülten” çıkartana ve Kınay kendisini arananlar listesinde bulana kadar. Ancak ne Türkiye ne de Avusturya Kınay’ı şu an itibarıyla Karayipler’e iade etmeyecektir.
Kınay “İlk önce çok şaşırdım. Sadece hayatım boyunca bütün yarattıklarım tahrip edilmedi, itibarım da mahvedilme tehlikesi ile karşı karşıya” diyor, “Haklarım için mücadele etmeye devam edeceğim ve atağa geçeceğim”. Bu bayagi masrafli olacak onun icin.Bugüne kadarki vekil masraflarını ödemek için Miami’de bulunan evini ederinden çok ucuza satmak zorunda kaldı. Satıştan gelen gelir de mahkeme vesayetine verildi. Şimdi ise kendisine ailesi ve uzun yıllardan beri ortağı olan Oğuz Serim mali yardımda bulunuyorlar. Adalara tedbir konulmasına karşı mahkemeye itirazda bulundu. Ancak sömürge valisi, Joe Grant adasının Sotheby’s üzerinden açık artırmaya çıkarılacağını duyurdu. Kınay ”Bu aşikar bir şekilde yasalara aykırıdır, itiraz davası devam ediyor” diyerek kızgınlığını belirtiyor.
Bu arada geçtiğimiz ilkbaharda New York’ta bir başarı elde eti. Dellis Cay’deki 30 villa alıcısından sekizi mahkemeye başvurarak tazminat ödenmesini talep ettiler. Ancak bu dava red edildi. Kendisinin ilk villa müşterilerinden olan Hollywood yıldızı Michael Douglas ve eşi Catherine Zeta Jones ise hiç bir zaman şikayette bulunmadılar.
Kınay, Dellis Cay projesini tekrar hayata geçirmek için her şeyi denemek istiyor. “Bütün bu olaylar dehşet verici. Ben her zaman sözümü tuttum. Daha gencim ve ticari hayatıma tabii kidevam edeceğim”.
“Olağanüstü kariyer, mutlak bir itibar”
O Avusturya Turizm ekonomisinin yıldızıydı. Öyle ki, ekonomi bakani Martin Bartenstein göğsüne bir devlet nişanı taktı. Dönemin Avusturya Havayolları Başkanı Mario Rehulka 1997 yılında ekonomi dergisi Trend tarafından “Yılın adamı”seçilen Kınay’a “Olağanüstü bir kariyer. Üstün müşteri kalitesi odaklı olup birinci kalite bir iş anlayışına ve işe sahiptir” diyerek işine karşı duyduğu ciddiyeti resmileştirdi. “Eğer yolsuzluk yapabileceğine dair enufak bir belirti dahi olsaydı, Avusturya Havayolları ona Touropa Tur Operatörünü satmazdı”. Eski hava yolları işletmecisi Niki Lauda, bir zamanlar en büyük müşterisi olan Kınay hakkında “sert bir müzakereci, ancak mükemmel bir iş kalitesi ve sözünün eri” dedi.
TUI Holding yönetim kurulu üyesi olan Eski Başbakan Almanların yönetime girmesi ile Kınay’ın da yönetim kurulu üyesi oldu. Aynı zamanda Magic Life Club’lardan çokmemnun bir tatilci olan Vranitzky “Tamamen işine angaje ve fikirlerine inandığım Kınay,bazen işlettiği otellerin sahipleri karşısında belki biraz fazla iyimser” diye düşünüyor.
Bu makale Avusturya KURIER gazetesinde 22 Temmuz 2012 tarihinde yayinlandi.
Statement of Dr Cem Kinay with respect to the Joe Grant Cay’s Sale
Istanbul, Turkey 18 December 2013
I understand from Turks and Caicos Islands media sources that a 200 acre parcel of Joe Grant Cay has been sold for $4.04m in October 2013 in a transaction that was never made public.
I was sure that one day, the truth about Joe Grant Cay’s true value will come to the light, Today, is my day. For the past 6 years, I have been living stripped of my basic human rights and assets just because the TCI Courts have concluded in connection with a political donation made to Michael Misick on 9 January 2007 “there to be a very strong probability that the money was paid as a bribe in order to ensure that the Defendant companies obtained the benefit of the proposed (Joe Grant Cay) development” disregarding the fact that there was in reality no benefit at all, as we have paid the true and accurate value of this land which was USD 3.2 million for the same 200 acres parcel back in 2008.
More specifically, on the matter of Joe Grant Cay’s valuation, His Hon Justice completely ignored the Government’s valuation report obtained from BCQS, an independent commercial appraiser who valued 200 acres parcel of Joe Grant Cay, at USD 3.2 million for commercial use, exactly the amount of money asked by the Government in June 2008, which my development companies have paid in full.
What is more astonishing was the fact that His Hon Judge ruled (Para 36, The Judgement) ‘When instructing BCQS to give an alternative valuation, McAllister Hanchell did not tell them of the proposed development, so that their valuation made no allowance for the intended use of the land.’. The Learned Chief Justice has failed to recognize that BCQS valuation report specifically stated on Page 7 Item 3.5 ‘It is assumed that planning permission is available for the subdivision of the land for residential plots or for a commercial use.’ By omitting BCQS’s clear statement specifying “commercial use” in its report, The Hon. Chief Justice violated our right to a fair trial, and unfairly favored the Turks and Caicos Islands Government by omitting what the true valuation report states. Instead, the Hon. Chief Justice relied on a series of valuation reports prepared by the Turks and Caicos Island’s own employee Mr. Hoza, which are at best confused. Mr. Hoza’s valuation reports valued the 200 acre parcel at a whopping 45 million for commercial use!
For those who doubt that the Development of Joe Grant Cay is not innocent, I have only one question: We have paid 3.2 million in 2008 for this 200 acre land, and today, 6 years later, the same land has been sold for 4.04 million in an open market transaction ! I ask you what happened to the alleged tens of millions of dollars that the Government and some of our opponents claimed that this land was supposed to be worth?
I have the answer: The alleged valuation of this island was a big lie ! Joe Grant Cay’s 200 acre was never valued more than what we paid for. That was the exact reason why many internationally repute valuation companies as well as all the local valuation companies have valued it at the exact value that we paid for it. That is why both Hon. Governor Tauwhare, and later on Hon. Governor Whetherell have approved and executed the sale of this 200 Acre land to us for USD 3.2 million, and that was why the sale was approved by the Attorney General, TCI Invest, Ministers, and the Premier.
In fact, there was no “favor” from anyone for Joe Grant Cay. In fact, we have paid the true value of this land, and the shameless dark forces took away from us alleging the “undervalue” sale. The evidence is before you, the same land is now sold for USD 4.04 million after 6 years.
In the past five years, I have been victimized by politics. My assets were frozen and hundreds of people lost their jobs. I could have developed Joe Grant Cay and create much needed jobs, and further tourism income for Turks and Caicos Islands. I was denied my fundamental right to a fair trial in TCI, a red notice application has been filed with the Interpol for my arrest. I am calling upon the TCI Government and the Attorney General to end these groundless accusations against me, return my assets, and clear my name as I have done nothing wrong.
